The Guardian — Opinion·Tuesday, 29 September 2026·1 min
Don’t get your kegs, keks and kex in a twist | Letters
别把啤酒桶、大麻花和牛蒡搞混了 | 读者来信
§
Zahaan Bharmal’s observation on the north-south pronunciation divide (Could we be about to see the end of northern English dialects? My experience – and the science – says aye, 23 September) is neatly corroborated in Rosie Webb’s otherwise delightfully rhyming children’s book Chimpanzees in Dungarees: reading aloud to our grandchildren, my Mancunian partner is forced to southernise the page about “gir-ar-ffes in scarfs”. A dozen miles from Webb’s Bristol base is a place that exemplifies the third, south-western variant: the long “aa” sound. I mean Bath, aka Baaff or Barth. The cities are close, but one is posh, the other not so much.
Please inform Mr Bharmal that up here in t’north as every Yorkshire (and Derbyshire) man knows, kegs can only store beer and the like. But kex is an umbelliferous flower to be seen while strolling through a meadow wearing your keks.
dialects are the cultural commons, not a luxury for the posh south. let the working class keep their words.
方言是工人阶级的文化公地,不是给南方那些装腔作势的人当奢侈品享用的。让劳工阶层保留他们的词汇吧。